Measuring the Right Moment

2018
Company

Unum 

Theme

Research Strategy • Systems Thinking • Journey Measurement • Evidence-Based Decision Making

The Situation

While consulting at Unum, I joined a cross-functional team working on a digital maternity leave experience designed to help expectant parents navigate the professional and personal responsibilities of pregnancy and parental leave.

The product supported employees throughout an emotional, highly personal journey—from planning leave and finding healthcare resources to communicating with managers and returning to work.

The team wanted to better understand the customer experience.

Their solution was straightforward.

Survey the users.

They had identified a population of roughly 500 users and planned to send one survey to people who had completed the experience and another to people currently using the product.

Before they finalized the plan, they asked for my perspective.

The Real Problem

The survey design wasn't wrong.

It just assumed every user's feedback represented the same experience.

As I thought about the customer journey, I realized something.

Someone who had completed maternity leave months ago would answer through the lens of memory.

Someone in the middle of maternity leave would likely be experiencing entirely different emotions.

Someone just beginning the process would have different expectations and concerns altogether.

If we combined those perspectives into only two surveys, we'd average away the most valuable insights.

We wouldn't know where in the journey people were struggling.

The Idea

Instead of organizing research around user populations, I proposed organizing it around customer journey stages.

Completed users would receive a single retrospective survey to provide an overall baseline, recognizing that their responses would naturally be influenced by hindsight.

Active users, however, would receive different surveys depending on where they were in their maternity leave journey.

I designed four stage-specific surveys:

  • New users pre-leave
  • Employees currently on leave
  • Employees returning to work
  • Inactive users

Each survey focused on the experiences that mattered during that specific stage. Examples:

  • scheduling appointments,
  • finding healthcare resources,
  • communicating with managers,
  • understanding benefits,
  • preparing to return to work.

Although the questions changed, every survey measured the same core dimensions:

  • Ease of use
  • User expectations
  • Understanding and comprehension
  • Confidence
  • Perceived success
  • Product value
  • Net Promoter Score (NPS)

This gave us something far more valuable than isolated survey responses.

It gave us a way to compare the customer experience across the entire journey.

The Outcome

The framework allowed the team to correlate customer sentiment across different stages while still isolating the specific moments where users experienced confusion, stress, or uncertainty.

Instead of asking whether people liked the product, we could identify:

  • where confidence declined,
  • where expectations weren't being met,
  • where additional guidance was needed,
  • and which product capabilities created the greatest value.

The team embraced the approach and implemented the surveys as an automated research program that continued after my contract ended.

Within the first week, nearly 270 responses had already been collected.

More importantly, the organization now had an ongoing measurement system rather than a one-time survey.

What I Learned

This project reinforced something I've come to believe throughout my career:

Research should follow the customer's experience—not the organization's reporting structure.

The quality of research depends as much on when you ask a question as what you ask.

By aligning research with the natural stages of a customer's journey, we gained richer, more actionable insights that informed future features, improved adoption, and created a clearer understanding of where the product delivered value—and where it still needed to improve.

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram